Project

In the latter half of the second millennium BCE, networks of trade and exchange developed throughout South Asia. Urban polities thrived on the extraction of upland forest products, feeding them into networks across the region, the Indian Ocean and the Bay of Bengal. Forest products included plant materials and animal by-products – such as timber, medicinal plants, dyes, resins, furs, skins, bones, and ivory – as well as metal ores and gemstones. Forest-dwellers, with their ecological knowledge, became key suppliers in the urban economies of Asia. In the early nineteenth century, the British colonial enterprise started to ‘legally’ appropriate forested land from indigenous owners, relegating them to a subaltern role in the global economy of the following centuries.

Indian upland forest-dwellers – like many other indigenous communities around the globe – are currently under threat from resource extraction, agricultural development and de-forestation as are the material remains of their cultures. Indian forest-dwelling communities are still perceived as a-historical, the geschichtslosen Völker of nineteenth century historiography, therefore research on their past is scant and inadequate. This is the result of a Eurocentric perspective that is still dominant today and relegates Indian upland forest-dwellers to the margins of history. The aim of the Nilgiri Archaeological Project is to change this view and develop a new multidisciplinary framework to study the pre-colonial history of Indian upland forest-dwellers. To this end, research will combine the theories of Subaltern Studies with those of environmental history, and integrate the methods of material culture studies, landscape and environmental archaeology, historical ethnobotany, ethnolinguistics, and textual analysis. The Nilgiri Archaeological Project will investigate museum collections, the built and natural landscape, archaeobotanical remains, early colonial herbaria and botanical literature, indigenous oral histories, and inscriptions in Old Kannada and Old Tamil.

Research focuses on the Nilgiri Mountains in southern India, a massif of some 2400 km² forming part of the Western Ghats mountain range. This is a region of montane subtropical forests with peaks over 2500 m. The area is the homeland of – at least – sixteen ethnic groups, which practice gathering and trading of forest products, swidden agriculture, pastoralism, and wage labour. This region has been selected because of the unique richness of excavated assemblages and structural remains. The chronological horizon of the Nilgiri Archaeological Project runs from the start of the Common Era to the early nineteenth century. According to limited archaeological and palaeoecological evidence, occupation of the Western Ghats started around the first century CE, when the demand for forest products – mainly black pepper and cardamom – increased due to booming Indo-Roman trade. In 1835, the British established the first tea plantation in the Nilgiris, which was followed by many others. This profoundly affected the ecology of the region. The chronological limits of our project are therefore drawn by these two key interventions in the landscape.

In order to achieve the project’s aim, the Nilgiri Archaeological Project has developed five research strands each prompting a research question.

Map of the study area of the Nilgiri Archaeological Project, the area north of the towns of Udhagamandalam and Kotagiri. Inset: location of the Nilgiris District within South India. (Map: Letizia Trinco).

Landscape

To what extent did the forest-dwellers of the Nilgiri Mountains communities adapt to, transform, and exploit the forested environment?

Megalithic tomb at Ezhukottai, on one of the NIlgiri mountaintops. (Photograph: Daniela De Simone).

The tops and ridges of the Nilgiri Monuntains are dotted with one or – more often – a group of megalithic tombs, which were excavated, in the 19th century, by British colonial officials, who also documented non-burial funerary monuments – such as dolmens and memorial stones. In order to answer the first research question, we will map the sites of burial and non-burial monuments of the area north of the towns of Udhagamandalam and Kotagiri (roughly 60 km²), where most of excavated burial sites concentrate, to reconstruct the funerary landscape of the region. Site distribution will then be analysed to determine

Dolmen at Kagucchi, on the Nilgiri Mountains. (Photograph: Letizia Trinco).

patterns of occupation and define the relation between burial and non-burial sites as well as between these sites and the surrounding environment. Landscape features that can lead to the identification of settlements will be given special attention since the settlements associated with the funerary monuments of the Nilgiri Mountains have never been discovered.

We will also collect pollen and phytolith samples to reconstruct the early ecology of the study area. The newly collected samples will enlarge the collection of pollens and phytoliths from the Nilgiri forests of the French Institute of Pondicherry, one of the largest in India, which is linked to its own herbarium and to others around the world.

Identity

What was the perception that the upland forest communities of the Nilgiri Mountains had of themselves and the world around them?

Grave goods excavated from the megalithic burials of the Nilgiri Mountains. (Photograph: British Museum).

Museum collections of Nilgiri grave goods excavated from megalithic burials in the nineteenth century offer a unique opportunity to analyse a large assemblage of archaeological artefacts unearthed in an Indian region of upland forests. Grave goods are the only excavated evidence we have of the past Nilgiri forest-dwellers since

Memorial stone at Melur, on the Nilgiri Mountains. (Photograph: Letizia Trinco).

settlements have never been discovered. The Nilgiri burial assemblages include ceramics, and terracotta, bronze, iron, gold and stone artefacts. The largest collection of Nilgiri grave goods is at the British Museum, another substantial collection is at the Government Museum in Chennai, and a small collection of terracotta figurines and potsherds is at the Museum für Asiatische Kunst in Berlin.

Given the importance of the study of funerary practices and burial assemblages in recovering the identity of the deceased and their community, in order to answer the second research question, we will carry out a comprehensive and systematic study of the museum collections of Nilgiri grave goods to establish a relative and absolute chronology of the grave goods from the Nilgiri Mountains, identify their findspots, reconstruct burial assemblages, and determine the source of imported items and the likely routes by which they came to the Nilgiris . In combination with the analysis of grave goods, we will also carry out an iconographical study of the reliefs sculpted on the memorial stones.

Upland-lowland Interactions

What do inscriptions in Old Kannada and literature in Old Tamil as well as contemporary oral histories of the forest-dwellers of the Nilgiri Mountains reveal of past upland-lowland interactions?

Inscription in Old Kannada dated to 1117 CE at the Pārśvanātha Jain temple at Chāmarājanagara in Karnataka. This is the earliest inscription mentioning the Nilgiri Mountains and its inhabitants. (Photograph: Nitin HP).

The earliest historical record mentioning the Nilgiri region and its inhabitants is a stone inscription in Old Kannada found in the Pārśvanātha Jain temple at Chāmarājanagara in Karnataka dated to 1117 CE. Copper-plates and stone inscriptions of the twelfth century found in the lowlands surrounding the Nilgiris attest the use of Old Kannada and are evidence that this language served as a lingua franca in the upland areas.

Photograph of a group of Toda men from the Nilgiri Mountains, taken by an unknown photographer from the Madras School of Arts in c. 1871-72. (Photograph: British Library).

Caṅkam literature is a corpus of Old Tamil texts, which is regarded as the classical literature of South India. It is dated ca. 100 BCE-250 CE and comprises anthologies of poems, which are classified into seven genres or tiṇais, each linked to a specific landscape; the kuṟiñci tiṇai sets its poems in a forested upland landscape. Tamil epics such as the Cilappatikāram (fifth century CE) and the Cīvakacintāmaṇi (tenth century CE) also contain chapters on the forests and the forest-dwellers.

The forest-dwellers of the Nilgiri Mountains speak Dravidian languages and dialects, and have a rich oral literary tradition: folktales, songs, and prayers.

In order to answer the third research question, we will analyse texts in Old Kannada and Old Tamil to reveal information about past upland-lowland relations, and understand how forests and forest-dwellers were perceived by South Indian urban societies and how the otherness of the forest-dwellers is constructed in external textual sources. We will then comparatively study the oral literature produced by the indigenous communities of the Nilgiri Mountains to reveal information on past upland-lowland relations and understand how the otherness of lowland people is constructed in these texts.

Traditional Ecological Knowledge

What was the knowledge of the forested ecosystem that the indigenous communities inhabiting the forests of the Western Ghats had?

Specimen of Acacia polyacantha Willd. (white cutch tree) collected in 1696 by Samuel Brown, an English surgeon and botanist, in the herbarium of the East India Company held at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. The plant is traditionally used in India to treat snakebites. (Photograph: Kew Gardens).

The Hortus Indicus Malabaricus (1678-1693), an illustrated treatise on flora of the Western Ghats (the mountain range including the Nilgiri massif), has been considered the key text on Indian botany for centuries. The Hortus was written in Latin

Copper plate engraving of a plant of Piper nigrum (black pepper) from the Hortus Indicus Malabaricus. Black pepper was one of the main forest products imported from India to Rome during the imperial period. (Photograph: Wellcome Collection).

by Hendrik van Rheede, Governor of Cochin for the Dutch East India Company. It consists of twelve volumes of 500 pages each on the medicinal use of 740 plants compiled over a period of thirty years and published between 1678 and 1693. The Hortus was a collaborative, multilingual project: healers from the Ezhava or forest-dwelling toddy tappers community collected plants and provided empirical functional taxonomies in Malayalam, while three Konkani brahmin scholars and Ayurvedic physicians verified the information on the Mahānikhaṇḍu, a Sanskrit medical text, and then summarised it in Konkani. The Hortus is the earliest text that explicitly relies on the ethnobotanical knowledge of a forest-dwelling community. Collections of flora from the Western Ghats assembled between the seventeenth and nineteenth century are held in the herbarium of the East India Company at the Royal Botanic Garden at Kew in London (approx. 800 plants). In order to answer the fourth research question, we will analyse the Hortus in combination with the EIC herbarium to reveal aspects of traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) prevalent in the Western Ghats before colonial botany became hegemonic.